the best punk rock record as voted by you
by Michele Christopher

It is over.

Before we start this, we really want to thank everyone for taking the time to join us in this process. We want to say a big thank you to all the sites who put this out, blogs who linked us, and people who kept coming in and nominating and voting. Without your participation, this would have been two people bitching about some obscure album telling each other which one is better. Sure, none of my choices even came close and for that matter, neither did Michele's, but that's besides the point.

You took the time to come here and vote. And for that, we thank you.

I know what you are thinking. "Shut up turtle. Tell us who won."

Hey. We just had to say thank you first. Now lets get on with this.

"Best Punk Record of All Time" was hard to define. We couldn't define it. So we left it up to you. That way when the cards fall down and the someone sticks and Ace in their sock, we can blame you for not seeing it. It our little way of saying don't blame us. You guys could have seen Lou putting the card in his sock just as easily as we could have. Multiple votes by a single IP were kicked. This vote was sent out to places like and others like it. Threads were started in other pages. So we kind of expected the Ramones to win.

We explained the rules to you before. Nominate, then vote. This isn't VH-1 and this isn't fucking Rolling Stone. We don't have some last say to make everything right. We stepped back on this one. In the other votes, we will admit that we voted like two or three times, but in this one, I voted once, Michele voted once and left the rest up to you.

So who won? What album do you think was the best all time punk rock record?

Black Flag - Damaged

We've both written about this album before, but the fact that it won this thing means it deserves something new.

I'll be honest, I'm glad Damaged won. Don't get me wrong; I love the Ramones, I'm a big fan from back in the beginning, but "best" is always a subjective term and, for me, "best" goes beyond just being a good, fun record, like the Ramones s/t is.

Damaged was a mind blowing album for me. All the punk I had been listening to before this - The Clash, Ramones, The Damned, etc. - seemed to be missing something in comparison. Damaged was my first real experience with hardcore. And it bit me, hard.

It's a raw album. And not in the way that, say, The Stooges were raw. Not the sound. The feeling. Listening to Damaged was like walking into an open wound. Maybe it was yours. Maybe it was someone else's. But when I listened to this, it was like opening a slit in my arm and letting the blood flow out. It was release. Letting it all out. It was a relentless assault of every part of me, physically and emotionally. That an album could be cathartic, energizing and paralyzing all at once is quite an accomplishment.

Personally, I think the best album really won. - M

What can I say about this album that hasn't already been said. This album was hardcore. The first to define a scene. It was like for the first time you could actually say we were doing something different. Circle Jerks fucked around with it but the never really got it. Don't ask me what X was doing. Something about love and wanting to fuck Lorna Doom. I didn't know where the hell those albums were going. First rule of hardcore. Girls don't exist. Sorry. But it's true. This was a monument to anger and frustration. Everything on here was about how fucked up your life is. You were the one eating cold three day old chow mein. You were the one who couldn't get out of bed cause you hated life. You were the one throwing beer bottles at the TV. You were the one who got arrested all the time. You were the one. You were hardcore. That was Damaged. - T

Black Flag Rise Above
Black Flag Depression
Black Flag No More
Black Flag Police Story


not my favorite, but then again, as I said, none of mine made it.


No one likes New Bomb Turks

/kicks dirt and walks away


Could've been worse. :)



yay yay yay!! and i didn't even go nuts with the voting like i did all the other times. (well, except the 2000's cuz who really cares)

no, it's not scientific and it doesn't really amount to a hill of beans, but i'm glad it won.

yes originators, blah blah blah, but black flag defined punk. they were raw and loud and annoying and my parents hated them. shit everybody hated them. except me. and the gang. RAWR.

(fuck you know i like them if they're from kalipornia and i still admit to it.)

thanks for the contest, you two. you rock.


I was really pushing for the Ramones, but I think Blag Flag is a great choice also.

Plus kali went RAWR. So it's solid.


i do want to say that for anyone reading this Cullen has started his vote for the Best Metal Song. So go over there and pick which song would make you say "We're not gonna take it! No! We ain't gonna take it! We're not gonna take it anymore!!!"

/oh, i had to say it



that was me who said that. i need to fix this thing


what do you wanna do with your life?

i wanna rock


I can't be upset about this. I put around 10 or 15 votes in for The Ramones, but Damaged is really great too, so I'm down with this result. Congrats Black Flag!


cullens post is on Totalfark. i submitted it.


awesome. South Bay quietly rocks the shit out of the world, having given it the BEST PUNK ROCK ALBUM EVER. fuck yeah.


Hey, THANKS turtle!


eXTReMe Tracker